Is it possible to lay a hard and fast rule on the Powers of Company Law Board under section 397/398 of Companies Act, 1956

Indian Company Law
Is it possible to lay a hard and fast rule on the Powers of Company  Law Board under section 397/398 of Companies Act, 1956

Why disputes arise in closely held companies   

Shareholder disputes are common in closely held companies. In public listed companies SEBI and Stock Exchange monitor allotments and governance, so scope for oppression is less. But in private companies when trust is lost between groups, each side tries to take control. Law gives protection under section 397/398 against oppression and mismanagement. Alternatives are Civil Court, CLB, or winding up in High Court. Civil Court jurisdiction is barred in company matters and winding up is not favored if company is going concern. So 397/398 before CLB is main remedy. But effectiveness and misuse are both concerns. This makes scope of CLB powers critical.

Conflicting views on clb powers    

There are many precedents on section 397/398 and section 402. Some judgments say CLB cannot exercise powers not expressly conferred. Others say CLB has elaborate powers to regulate affairs and put an end to matters complained of. Section 402 lists specific powers but says "without prejudice to generality". This creates confusion. Corporate professionals are in dilemma whether CLB can act beyond section 402. Variety of situations come before Board. Strict technical reading will limit CLB. Liberal reading may give wide discretion. Hence courts had to step in to give guidance.

Supreme court in radharamanan case    

Hon’ble Supreme Court in M.S.D.C. Radharamanan Vs. M.S.D. Chandrasekara Raja 2008 6 SCC 750 gave important clarity. Court said no hard and fast rule can be laid on CLB jurisdiction. Complex situations arise. Acts of omission and commission must be qua management. But just and equitable test used in winding up cannot be totally excluded from 397. CLB must first see interest of company vis-a-vis shareholders. It must ask whether winding up serves interest or subverts it. CLB should not shut doors on sheer technicality even if jurisdiction under section 402 is needed to prevent chaos. If literal interpretation is taken, CLB may be powerless. But since jurisdiction is couched in wide terms, CLB can grant diverse reliefs to keep company functioning.

Why rigid rule is not possible    

Every 397/398 case has different facts. Oppression may be by diversion of funds, denial of rights, or deadlock. Mismanagement may be financial or administrative. Company may be profitable or loss making. Employees, creditors, public interest may be involved. If hard rule is laid, genuine cases will suffer. If too wide power is given, misuse may happen. Therefore SC approach is correct: CLB must balance. It must safeguard company and majority of members, grant relief that is beneficial, and avoid technicality. At same time settled principles must be followed so that discretion is not arbitrary.

Conclusion    

Powers of company law board section 397 398 companies act 1956 cannot be put in a straight jacket. Radharamanan 2008 lays down that flexibility is needed. CLB must look at interest of company, avoid chaos, and use section 402 as guide not limit. In 2010, with increasing disputes in closely held companies, this approach helps CLB regulate affairs and put an end to matters complained of without being bound by rigid rules.

Nathan & Associates Logo

Providing top-tier legal consultancy with a focus on integrity, excellence, and client success.

facebook
linkedin
twitter
instagram

Quick Links

Law Firm Services

© 2020 Nathan And Associates – All rights reserved.